Paranthrene tabaniformis (poplar clearwing moth)
- Taxonomic Tree
- Notes on Taxonomy and Nomenclature
- Distribution Table
- Hosts/Species Affected
- Growth Stages
- List of Symptoms/Signs
- Biology and Ecology
- Natural enemies
- Notes on Natural Enemies
- Means of Movement and Dispersal
- Plant Trade
- Wood Packaging
- Environmental Impact
- Detection and Inspection
- Similarities to Other Species/Conditions
- Prevention and Control
- Distribution Maps
Don't need the entire report?
Generate a print friendly version containing only the sections you need.Generate report
PicturesTop of page
IdentityTop of page
Preferred Scientific Name
- Paranthrene tabaniformis Rottemburg, 1775
Preferred Common Name
- poplar clearwing moth
Other Scientific Names
- Aegeria tabaniformis Rottemburg, 1775
- Aegeria tricincta (Harris, 1839)
- Albuna denotata (H. Edwards, 1882)
- Paranthrene rhingiaeformis var. intermedia (Le Cerf, 1916)
- Paranthrene tabaniformis f. sangaica (Bartel, 1912)
- Paranthrene tricincta f. oslari (Engelhardt, 1946)
- Sciapteron tabaniforme Rottemburg, 1775
- Sciapteron tabaniforme var. kungessana (Alpheraky, 1882)
- Sciapteron tabaniformis Rottemburg, 1775
- Sesia crabroniformis (Laspeyres, 1801)
- Sesia serratiformis (Freyer, 1842)
- Sesia synagriformis (Rambur, 1866)
- Sesia tabaniformis Rottemburg, 1775
- Sphinx asiliformis ([Denis & Schiffermüller], 1775)
- Sphinx rhingiaeformis (Hübner, 1790)
- Sphinx tabaniformis Rottemburg, 1775
- Sphinx vespiformis (Newman, 1832)
International Common Names
- English: dusky clearwing; dusky, clearwing; poplar twig borer
- Spanish: oruga perforadora del chopo
- French: petite sésie du peuplier
- Russian: Malaya topolevaya stekljannitsa; tiomnokrilaya stekljannitsa
- Chinese: poplar small aegerid
- Portuguese: larva perforadora do chopo
Local Common Names
- Bulgaria: malka topolova staklenka
- Czechoslovakia (former): nesytka ovádová
- Finland: varjolasisiipi
- Germany: Glasfluegler, Kleiner Pappel-; Kleiner Pappelglasschwärmer
- Italy: tarlo vespa del pioppo
- Netherlands: populiereglasvlinder
- Poland: przeziernik topolowiec
- Serbia: mali topolin staklokrilac
- Sweden: svart poppelglasvinge
- PARHTA (Paranthrene tabaniformis)
Taxonomic TreeTop of page
- Domain: Eukaryota
- Kingdom: Metazoa
- Phylum: Arthropoda
- Subphylum: Uniramia
- Class: Insecta
- Order: Lepidoptera
- Family: Sesiidae
- Genus: Paranthrene
- Species: Paranthrene tabaniformis
Notes on Taxonomy and NomenclatureTop of page Paranthrene tabaniformis belongs to the Lepidopteran family Sesiidae which includes over 1000 described species (Heppner and Duckworth, 1981; Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988). The family is represented by two subfamilies, Tinthiinae and Sesiinae (Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995), and P. tabaniformis belongs to the Sesiinae.
P. tabaniformis was described as Sphinx tabaniformis (Rottemburg, 1775). In the Palearctic region this species has also been reported under the following synonyms: Sphinx asiliformis (Denis and Schiffermüller, 1775), Sphinx rhingiaeformis (Hübner, 1790), Sesia crabroniformis (Laspeyres, 1801), Sphinx vespiformis (Newman, 1832), Sesia serratiformis (Freyer, 1842) and Sesia synagriformis (Rambur, 1866). The genus Paranthrene has been established by Hübner (1819). Different forms and aberrations of P. tabaniformis were also described in the Old World: Sciapteron tabaniforme var. kungessana (Alpheraky, 1882), Paranthrene rhingiaeformis var. intermedia (Le Cerf, 1916) and Paranthrene tabaniformis f. sangaica (Bartel, 1912). Recently a geographical form insolitus of P. tabaniformis from Syria was reported (Templado, 1964), but this is now recognized as a different valid species, Paranthrene insolitus Le Cerf, 1914 (Heppner and Duckworth, 1981; Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995).
The Nearctic species P. tricincta was described as Aegeria tricincta (Harris, 1839). It was also reported as Albuna denotata (H. Edwards, 1882). Engelhardt (1946, cited in Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988) considered P. tabaniformis to occur only in Europe and maintained P. tricincta as the North American element of the closely related species pair on the basis of slight differences in the male genitalia. According to Eichlin and Duckworth (1988), however, these differences are well within the normal range of variation in the species and do not justify maintaining P. tricincta as a separate species.
Two subspecies have been established in the Western Palaearctic: Paranthrene tabaniformis tabaniformis (Rottemburg, 1775) and Paranthrene tabaniformis synagriformis (Rambur, 1866) (de Freina, 1997). An Asiatic subspecies, Paranthrene tabaniformis kungessana (Alphéraky, 1882), occurs in Palaearctic China (de Freina, 1997).
DescriptionTop of page Eggs are black with elliptical shape (0.8-0.9 mm length, 0.55 mm width and 0.35 mm height). The surface of the chorion is micro-sculptured.
Neonate larvae are light grey or rose-coloured. After the third stage, the larvae have an off-white or light yellow body with a dark longitudinal dorsal stripe (see Pictures). The head and prothorax scute are brown. There are two brown spines on the last abdominal segment. The larvae which become male and female adults have six and seven stages, respectively (Turundaevskaya, 1981). At successive stages of their development, larval dimensions are 1.2-2 mm, 2-8 mm, 6-15 mm, 9-23 mm, 15-30 mm, 17-31 mm, and 19-32 mm (Georgiev, 1995a). Head capsule widths of successive larval stages are on average 0.36 mm, 0.74 mm, 1.33 mm, 1.76 mm, 2.24 mm, 2.88 mm, and 3.71 mm (Georgiev, 1995a).
Pupae are 13-21 mm in length and 4-6 mm in width. They are initially light brown (see Pictures), later becoming brown, russet and blackish (see Pictures). At the end of pupal development, the yellow rings of the abdomen are seen through the pupal skin. The male and female pupae weigh on average 160 and 223 mg, respectively (Turundaevskaya, 1981).
The adults of P. tabaniformis resemble wasps (see Pictures). They are bluish-black with a wingspan from 18 to 35 mm. There are many yellow spots and stripes on the head, thorax and legs. The forewings are elongate, dark brown without transparent cells distally. The hindwings are entirely transparent, shorter and broader than forewings. The wings are bordered with brown fringes. The anal tuft is blue-black, larger in males than in females.
In the subspecies tabaniformis, abdominal segments 2, 4, 6, and 7 (in males) are banded with yellow scales (see Pictures). The upper surface of the antennae is black and the lower surface is rust-coloured.
The European form rhingiaeformis has yellow rings on all abdominal segments.
The Nearctic form denotata differs by having abdominal segments 3 and 5 narrowly edged posteriorly with yellow in both sexes, and the anal tuft of the males mixed with some yellow. Another Nearctic form, oslari, has all abdominal segments except segment 1 with yellow bands, widest on segments 2 and 6, narrower on 3 and 5; the female has more yellow than the male on all the segments mentioned (Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988).
The subspecies synagriformis is characterized by light brown antennae and forewings, metathorax with two small yellow spots and yellow rings on all abdominal segments, which are more prominent than in the nominate form (de Freina, 1997).
DistributionTop of page P. tabaniformis is a Holarctic speces. The nominate subspecies, P. tabaniformis tabaniformis occurs in the whole of Europe with the exception of the southern part of the Iberian Peninsula, Asia Minor, Near East, Caucasus to Central Asia and India, the whole of Siberia, Mongolia, Amur region to North Japan (Hokkaido) and North America (de Freina, 1997). In North America P. tabaniformis occurs from the eastern half of the United States through the Midwest (Oklahoma) and Rocky Mountains, across southern Canada and north into Alaska (Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988).
The West Palaearctic form rhingiaeformis, which does not differ from P. tabaniformis tabaniformis in genitalia, occurs more in Southern and Eastern Central Europe (de Freina, 1997).
P. tabaniformis synagriformis is distributed in North Africa from Morocco (High and Middle Atlas and in the western coastal regions) to Egypt, southern and central Spain, southern Portugal and south-eastern France (de Freina, 1997).
The Asiatic subspecies, P. tabaniformis kungessana occurs in Palaearctic China (de Freina, 1997). The form sangaica is also known from China (Templado, 1964).
Distribution TableTop of page
The distribution in this summary table is based on all the information available. When several references are cited, they may give conflicting information on the status. Further details may be available for individual references in the Distribution Table Details section which can be selected by going to Generate Report.
|Continent/Country/Region||Distribution||Last Reported||Origin||First Reported||Invasive||Reference||Notes|
|Armenia||Widespread||Turundaevskaya, 1981; Gorbunov, 1986|
|China||Widespread||Du et al., 1984; Du et al., 1985; Miao et al., 1985|
|-Heilongjiang||Widespread||Miao et al., 1989|
|-Jilin||Present||Schmutzenhofer et al., 1996|
|-Liaoning||Present||Schmutzenhofer et al., 1996|
|-Nei Menggu||Present||Schmutzenhofer et al., 1996|
|Georgia (Republic of)||Widespread||Gorbunov, 1986|
|India||Present||de Freina, 1997|
|Iran||Present||Chodjai et al., 1977|
|Iraq||Present||Chodjai et al., 1977|
|Japan||Present||de Freina, 1977|
|-Hokkaido||Present||de Freina, 1977|
|Lebanon||Present||Chodjai et al., 1977|
|Mongolia||Present||de Freina, 1977; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962|
|Syria||Present||Chodjai et al., 1977|
|Turkey||Widespread||Chodjai et al., 1977; Acatay, 1959; Yüksel, 1998|
|Egypt||Present||de Freina, 1997|
|Morocco||Present||Templado, 1964; de Freina, 1997|
|Canada||Present||Morris, 1956; Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988|
|USA||Present||Morris, 1956; Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988|
|-Mississippi||Present||Solomon et al., 1982|
|Bulgaria||Widespread||Georgiev, 1995b; Keremidciev, 1966|
|Czechoslovakia (former)||Widespread||Srot, 1966|
|Denmark||Present||Fibiger and Kristensen, 1974|
|Finland||Present||Fibiger and Kristensen, 1974; Vuola and Korpela, 1977|
|Former USSR||Unconfirmed record||Gorbunov, 1986|
|Greece||Widespread||Kalidis, 1962; Georgopulos, 1956|
|Hungary||Widespread||Szontagh, 1965a; Szontagh, 1965b; Toth, 1970|
|Ireland||Present||Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|Italy||Widespread||Arru and Lapietra, 1974; Bertucci, 1986|
|Lithuania||Present||Buda et al., 1988|
|Luxembourg||Present||Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|Macedonia||Present||Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|Netherlands||Widespread||Moraal and, 1993; Moraal, 1996|
|Norway||Present||Fibiger and Kristensen, 1974|
|Poland||Widespread||Strojny, 1958; Schnaiderova, 1980|
|Portugal||Present||Nogueira and Ferreira, 1968; Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|Romania||Widespread||Ceianu, 1962; Ceianu et al., 1967|
|Russian Federation||Present||Present based on regional distribution.|
|-Central Russia||Present||Kozhanchikov, 1955; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Suhareva, 1978|
|-Eastern Siberia||Present||Kozhanchikov, 1955; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Suhareva, 1978|
|-Northern Russia||Present||Kozhanchikov, 1955; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Suhareva, 1978|
|-Russian Far East||Present||Kozhanchikov, 1955; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Suhareva, 1978|
|-Southern Russia||Present||Kozhanchikov, 1955; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Suhareva, 1978|
|-Western Siberia||Present||Kozhanchikov, 1955; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Suhareva, 1978|
|Slovakia||Present||Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|Slovenia||Present||Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|Spain||Widespread||Dafauce and Astiaso, 1964; Templado, 1964; Dafauce, 1975|
|Sweden||Present||Fibiger and Kristensen, 1974|
|Switzerland||Present||Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|UK||Widespread||South, 1939; Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995|
|Yugoslavia (former)||Widespread||Vasic, 1966; Jodal, 1967; Jodal, 1986|
HabitatTop of page P. tabaniformis is a common pest in poplar nurseries, young poplar plantations and on ornamental poplars in urban environments (Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Kailidis, 1962; Szontagh, 1965a, b; Ceianu et al., 1967; Jodal, 1986; Moraal et al., 1993; Georgiev, 2000a). It is also associated with Populus and Salix species in floodplain forests.
Hosts/Species AffectedTop of page P. tabaniformis feeds mainly on poplars (Populus spp.) and rarely on willows (Salix spp.) (Templado, 1964; Fibiger and Kristensen, 1974; Vuola and Korpela, 1977; Postner, 1978; Turundaevskaya, 1981; Bertucci, 1986). In North America this species is considered to feed primarily on Salix spp. but has also been observed on Populus spp. (Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988).
In poplar nurseries and plantations, all cultivated hybrid poplars from Leuce section (clones of Populus alba), Aigeiros section (clones of P. nigra, P. deltoides and P. x euramericana [P. x canadensis]), Tacamahaca section (clones of P. trichocarpa [P. balsamifera subsp. trichocarpa]) and clones of Aigeiros x Tacamahaca are infested to varying degrees by P. tabaniformis (Ceianu et al., 1967; Georgiev, 1995a). No clones resistant to the pest attacks have been noted in field observations (Dafauce, 1975; Lapietra, 1976; Moraal, 1996). P. tabaniformis causes serious damage on ornamental poplars in urban areas (Goidanich, 1983; Georgiev and Delkov, 1997; Georgiev, 2000a).
Some other hosts of P. tabaniformis include: Hippophäe rhamnoides (Lastuvka and Lastuvka, 1995), Betula alba [B. pubescens] and the mistletoe Loranthus europaeus on Salix (de Freina, 1997).
Growth StagesTop of page Vegetative growing stage
SymptomsTop of page The following common symptoms indicate that host plants are infested by P. tabaniformis: swellings (galls) on the stems and branches, larval entrance holes with expelled frass, adult exit holes with pupal skins, and stem breakage.
The larvae of P. tabaniformis bore into the poplar stems producing galleries in the wood. In the nursery, infested 1-year-old poplar seedlings form symmetric galls at the points of larval feeding (see Pictures). These galls grow slowly until the end of the plant growth period.
Infested host plants are characterized by external openings of the larval galleries with frass (faecal material and wood particles) protruding from them (see Pictures).
After adult emergence, exit holes are clearly visible with a portion of the pupal skin (see Pictures).
In poplar plantations, infested 2- and 3-year-old trees are characterized by local swellings at the points of infection, whereas the oldest trees are without swellings. There is also frass expelled from external openings of the larval galleries. Larvae from different generations can develop on the same place during successive years. In this case, large external openings are formed at the points of infection (see Pictures).
Severe infestations of the trees can result in stem breakage under wind impact.
List of Symptoms/SignsTop of page
|Roots / internal feeding|
|Stems / galls|
|Stems / internal feeding|
|Stems / lodging; broken stems|
|Stems / visible frass|
Biology and EcologyTop of page P. tabaniformis requires 1 or 2 years to complete its life cycle. It has a 2-year cycle of development in northern parts of its geographical distribution (Northern Europe and Siberia) (Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Srot, 1966; Vuola and Korpela, 1977; Postner, 1978) and a 1-year cycle in southern parts: Spain, Morocco, Algeria, Southern France (Templado, 1964), Italy (Bertucci, 1986), Greece (Georgopulos, 1956), Bulgaria (Georgiev, 1995b), Romania (Ceianu et al., 1967), Serbia (Jodal, 1967), Poland (Schnaiderova, 1980), Armenia, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, and Northern Kazakhstan (Turundaevskaya, 1981). In Hungary, some of the P. tabaniformis population is univoltine, and the rest takes 2 years to complete its development (Szontagh, 1965b). In North America, P. tabaniformis has a 2-year cycle of development (Eichlin and Duckworth, 1988).
In southern parts of its range, P. tabaniformis adults emerge from May to July or August (Ceianu et al., 1967; Arru and Lapietra, 1974; Turundaevskaya, 1981; Bertucci, 1986; Georgiev, 1995b). In the Netherlands, flight is observed from the end of May or early June until mid September (Moraal et al., 1988). Although the emergence period is very long (about 2-3 months; Moraal et al., 1988; Georgiev, 1995b), 60-90% of adults have been observed to appear in 20-30 days (Srot, 1966; Ceianu et al., 1967; Georgiev, 1995b). Adults emerge during the daytime from about 7.00 to 18.00 h, peaking between 9.00 and 13.00 h (Ceianu et al., 1967; Georgiev, 1995a). The sex ratio is usually 1:1. Adults visit flowers to obtain nectar and are observed on Taraxacum officinale (Turundaevskaya, 1981), Sambucus ebulus, Spiraea sp., Ligustrum, Valeriana spp. and Vincetoxicum hirundinaria (de Freina, 1997). The adults live 6-13 days (Turundaevskaya, 1981).
Some hours after emergence, female adults commence 'calling' behaviour (the act of emitting a sex pheromone to lure males for mating) (see Pictures). Copulation is observed in the daytime (13.00-19.00 h), peaking between 14.00 and 16.00 h (Georgiev, 1995a).
Female fecundity varies between 50 and 600 eggs, with an average of 310-360 (Ceianu et al., 1967; Turundaevskaya, 1981; Georgiev, 1995a). The females emerge mature, and oviposition begins soon after mating. The eggs are laid singly on the stems or branches near bark scars or crevices in the bark or are dropped near the base of the plant. The embryonic period lasts 10-15 days (Ceianu et al., 1967; Bertucci, 1986; Georgiev, 1995a). After hatching, the larvae cannot bore through the rough bark but find ready access to the cambium through wounds. The neonates can cover distances up to 137 cm to find a place to invade the tree (Moraal, 1989). If the hatching larvae cannot quickly locate a suitable entry point, they will soon desiccate; dry climate during the embryonic stage can cause mortality of up to 90% of the insect population (Ceianu et al., 1967). The larvae feed at first on inner bark, boring later into the wood-producing galleries. Frass is expelled from galleries through the entrance holes. Sometimes P. tabaniformis larvae are found in twig galls caused by Saperda populnea (Strojny, 1958).
The larvae have six or seven stages (Turundaevskaya, 1981). They overwinter in the third to fifth stages, and rarely in the sixth stage (Georgiev, 1995a). After hibernating during the winter, the larvae feed again and become fully grown in early spring. At the end of larval development, galleries reach up to 11-15 cm. However, the galleries in the stems of one-year-old poplar seedlings are longer than the galleries in the stems and branches of the oldest trees (see Pictures).
When the eggs are placed in bark crevices near ground level, newly hatched larvae bore in the roots or inside the bark. They make tunnels in the wood or between bark and wood.
P. tabaniformis mature larvae pupate in chambers in larval galleries. The pupae are observed in the heart of one-year-old poplar seedlings or under the bark of stems and branches of oldest trees (Georgiev, 1995a). Pupation occurs mostly in the upper parts of larval galleries over the entrance holes. Before pupating, the larvae bore lateral exit holes covered only by a very thin layer of wood and bark particles. They do not make cocoons. The pupal development lasts for 20-24 days at 16-18°C or 13-16 days at 22-25°C (Georgiev, 1995a).
Natural enemiesTop of page
|Natural enemy||Type||Life stages||Specificity||References||Biological control in||Biological control on|
Notes on Natural EnemiesTop of page The complex of natural enemies of P. tabaniformis includes predators, parasitoids and micropathogens.
Among the predators, some woodpeckers are the most important in reducing P. tabaniformis populations (Szontagh, 1965a; Ceianu et al., 1967). In poplar nurseries the mortality of P. tabaniformis caused by woodpeckers reaches about 67-93% of the overwintering population of the pest (Georgiev, 1995a). The action of the woodpeckers, however, could be harmful because they destroy the poplar stems (Srot, 1966; Ceianu et al., 1967).
The egg parasitoid Telenomus phalaenarum was observed in the Netherlands in a poplar plantation adjacent to a mixed forest (Moraal, 1989a). No parasitoids have been found in large poplar plantations (Moraal, 1996).
Thirty-seven hymenopteran and dipteran larval and nymphal parasitoids of P. tabaniformis have been established and reported by many authors (e.g. Thompson, 1957; Srot, 1958, 1966; Gyorfi, 1959, 1963; Ceballos, 1960; Ceianu, 1962; Grechkin and Vorontzov, 1962; Kailidis, 1962, 1970; Szontagh, 1965a, 1971; Ceianu et al., 1967; Lapietra, 1967; Postner, 1978; Bertucci, 1986; Tobias, 1986; Moraal, 1987; You et al., 1987; La Salle and Huang, 1994; Georgiev and Tsankov, 1995; Hubenov and Georgiev, 1996; Kolarov and Georgiev, 1997; Georgiev, 2000a, b, 2001a, b, c). The genera Dolichomitus, Lissonata, Apanteles and Bracon all include several species parasitic on P. tabaniformis.
Some parasitoid species play an important role as biocontrol agents of P. tabaniformis. There is only scarce information about the biology and ecology of the parasitoids in the entomological literature.
Apanteles evonymellae [Dolichogenidea evonymellae] is found in all areas studied in Bulgaria (Georgiev, 2001a). It is a solitary endoparasitoid and develops in early-stage (first- to fourth-instar) host larvae and overwinters as a larva in the host. The species is bivoltine, but only the second generation is associated with P. tabaniformis. The life cycle of A. evonymellae is not well synchronized with P. tabaniformis larval development. In the spring the adult parasitoids appear in April about a month prior to emergence of P. tabaniformis and must develop in alternate hosts. Prior to their death, parasitized P. tabaniformis larvae construct conical structures, 'refuges' of frass and silk threads over the external openings of the larval galleries (see Pictures). A. evonymellae pupates in these refuges after the host's death (see Pictures). This modified behaviour of the parasitized host larvae probably protects the pupae of A. evonymellae from hyperparasites and predators. A. evonymellae kills 2-35% of overwintering host larvae in various regions of Bulgaria (Georgiev, 2001a). Very high levels (55-60%) of parasitism caused by this species are also observed in the Netherlands (Moraal, 1989b, 1996).
Eriborus terebrans [Diadegma terebrans] was observed for the first time as a parasitoid of P. tabaniformis by Ceianu (1962). In Italy it parasitizes an average of 50% of P. tabaniformis larvae in some areas of the Po basin (Lapietra, 1967). This species is a solitary internal parasitoid which develops two generations per year in mid-stage host larvae (Georgiev, 2001b). E. terebrans pupates in the larval galleries (see Pictures). Adult parasitoids of the overwintering generation appear between late April/early May, and June or July. The peak activity of E. terebrans adults coincides only with the beginning of host emergence, which results in low levels of parasitism. Parasitoid adults of the summer generation appear in late June-mid August. In this period enough larvae of the host are suitable for attacking and parasitism reaches about 24-39% at some sites in Bulgaria. Some parasitized P. tabaniformis larvae construct tunnel structures of frass and silk threads over the external openings of the galleries (see Pictures). It is possible that these structures also protect parasitoid cocoons from natural enemies.
Pristomerus rufiabdominalis and P. vulnerator are solitary internal parasitoids of P. tabaniformis (Georgiev, 2001c). Their life cycles are not in good synchrony with host larval development. In the spring the parasitoids appear in late May-early June and their flight periods usually considerably precede the adult emergence of the host. Both Pristomerus species are bivoltine, but only one generation of the parasitoids is connected with P. tabaniformis. The more important species, P. vulnerator, kills 2-15% of the pest larvae.
Other parasitoid species have also been observed to kill a significant portion of the P. tabaniformis larval population. In Greece, Bracon fulvipes is sometimes able to destroy 10-65% of the host larvae, and Apantales laevigatus [Dolichogenidea laevigata] 10-50% of the larvae (Kailidis, 1962). In Romania, B. discoideus parasitises up to 35% of P. tabaniformis larvae (Ceianu et al., 1967).
The remaining parasitoids are not very important enemies of P. tabaniformis and together they usually kill no more than 5-11% of the pest (Szontagh, 1965b; Ceianu et al., 1967; Turundaevskaya, 1981; Georgiev and Tsankov, 1995; Georgiev, 2000b).
P. tabaniformis larvae are affected by the entomopathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana. Injection of a conidial suspension into the entrance boreholes of P. tabaniformis gives 50% field control in Italy (Cavalcaselle, 1975) and 94-98% laboratory and field control in Poland (Schnaiderowa and Swiezynska, 1977). In floodplain habitats the larvae of P. tabaniformis are infected by Fusarium sp., Aspergillus sp. and Penicillium sp. (Turundaevskaya, 1981).
Introduction of a suspension of the nematode Neoaplectana carpocapsae [Steinernema carpocapsae] into larval boreholes of P. tabaniformis results in 97.5-100% mortality of the pest (Wouters, 1977; Cavalcaselle and Deseo, 1984).
Means of Movement and DispersalTop of page Adults of P. tabaniformis are good fliers but almost nothing is known about the flight distances of the female adults. According to Moraal et al. (1993), however, the females can fly over short distances of at least 250 m from infested poplar stands to attack newly planted poplars.
Long-distance spread occurs through silvicultural practices or commercial movement of infested poplar seedlings for planting (Georgiev, 1995a; Moraal, 1996).
Poplar wood is not considered to present a likely pathway for spread to new areas.
Plant TradeTop of page
|Plant parts liable to carry the pest in trade/transport||Pest stages||Borne internally||Borne externally||Visibility of pest or symptoms|
|Bark||eggs||Yes||Pest or symptoms usually visible to the naked eye|
|Stems (above ground)/Shoots/Trunks/Branches||eggs; larvae; nymphs; pupae||Yes||Yes||Pest or symptoms usually visible to the naked eye|
|Wood||larvae; nymphs; pupae||Yes||Pest or symptoms usually visible to the naked eye|
|Plant parts not known to carry the pest in trade/transport|
|Fruits (inc. pods)|
|True seeds (inc. grain)|
Wood PackagingTop of page
|Wood Packaging not known to carry the pest in trade/transport|
|Loose wood packing material|
|Processed or treated wood|
|Solid wood packing material with bark|
|Solid wood packing material without bark|
ImpactTop of page In Southern and Central Europe, P. tabaniformis is the principal xylophagous insect pest in poplar nurseries and young plantations (Ceianu et al., 1968; Kailidis, 1970; Arru, 1975). It is considered to be responsible for about 10% of total damage to production (Szontagh, 1965b). When outbreaks occur the pest is able to infest up to 40% of 1-year-old poplar seedlings in nurseries, which must be destroyed (Georgiev, 1995a).
Environmental ImpactTop of page P. tabaniformis occurs in natural poplar and willow stands, poplar plantations and urban systems. Infested host plants produce characteristic swellings and deformations. The impact of the pest on the natural environment is not significant, but could result in strong aesthetic damage to young ornamental poplar trees in settlements (Georgiev, 2000a).
Detection and InspectionTop of page Poplar stems and branches must be examined carefully for galls, larval entrance holes with expelled frass, and for adult exit holes with pupal skins.
In poplar nurseries and plantations, pheromone traps baited with synthetic sex attractants can be set, to determine the emergence time of the pest. Sex attractant dispensers containing 1 mg (3E, 13Z)-3, 13-octadecadien-1-ol have been established to be very effective (Voerman and Wouters, 1980; Moraal et al., 1993). The dispensers retain their effectiveness for at least 2 months. Monitoring can be accomplished with sticky traps (Voerman and Wouters, 1980; Allegro, 1992; Moraal et al., 1993) and 'lure and kill' devices (Moraal et al., 1993). The traps must be set before the beginning of P. tabaniformis adult emergence. It is important to note that in young poplars males fly at lower levels, up to 3.0 m, but in old stands the number of males captured increases with increasing height of the traps (Moraal et al., 1993).
Similarities to Other Species/ConditionsTop of page The West Palaearctic species Paranthrene insolita and P. diaphana and the Nearctic P. dollii are similar in the adult stage. Characters distinguishing them from P. tabaniformis can be found mainly in genitalia and in superficial colour and pattern.
The damage caused by P. tabaniformis on branches of young poplar trees could be confused with the damage caused by Saperda populnea. However, P. tabaniformis galls are situated mostly on the stems and are without the horseshoe-shaped furrows made by adult females of S. populnea before they start laying eggs.
Prevention and ControlTop of page
Due to the variable regulations around (de)registration of pesticides, your national list of registered pesticides or relevant authority should be consulted to determine which products are legally allowed for use in your country when considering chemical control. Pesticides should always be used in a lawful manner, consistent with the product's label.
Phytosanitary and Preventive Measures
Effective preventive chemical control of P. tabaniformis in nurseries is required (Moraal, 1996). Preventive measures are to provide winter inspection of all planting stock and destruction of infested material (Dafauce, 1962), to plant poplar seedlings on uninfested sites and to keep the trees vigorous by means of fertilizer application and control of foliage pests (Bertucci, 1986). Another preventive measure is to avoid wounding of the trees which makes them more attractive for depositing eggs of the pest. Pruning of trees should not be carried out prior to or during the P. tabaniformis flight period (Georgiev, 1995a; Moraal, 1996).
Field studies on poplar infestations by P. tabaniformis have found no resistant poplar species or clones (Ceianu et al., 1967; Lapietra, 1976; Georgiev, 1995a). Although differences in attack rates have been observed, there is no statistically reliable data to designate clones which are more or less resistant to the pest attack (Moraal, 1996). Fast-growing poplars are thought to be more tolerant because larval galleries are overgrown more rapidly and the risk of stem-snapping decreases strongly. This can be achieved by planting in suitable locations and using clones which are known to be rapid starters.
Although the pathogenic fungus Beauveria bassiana and pathogenic nematode Neoaplectana carpocapsae [Steinernema carpocapsae] have been tested successfully against P. tabaniformis (Cavalcaselle, 1975; Schnaiderowa and Swiezynska, 1977; Wouters, 1977; Cavalcaselle and Deseo, 1984), practical methods for biological control of the pest have still not been achieved.
Parasitoids of P. tabaniformis appear to be the major biotic factor in maintaining low pest population density (Georgiev, 2000a, 2001a, b, c). They may be a very promising tool in devising a strategy for management of the pest. Some biological characteristics, such as freedom from any hyperparasites, and appearance before the host, can increase the beneficial impact of the parasitoids in poplar plantations. For example, it is well known that the most important parasitoids emerge about a month before P. tabaniformis (Georgiev and Tsankov, 1995; Georgiev, 2001a,b,c) and if some pest control against other pests in this period is needed, it is advisable to use selective larval insecticides. In this way, the flying adult parasitoids will not be affected and can exert an additional impact on the pest. In poplar nurseries, seedlings infested by xylophagous insects are usually burnt. It would be better, however, to put the cuttings with P. tabaniformis larvae in containers covered by plastic netting with 5x5 mm mesh-openings. The net will contain the pest moths but will let the parasitoid adults through, which will increase the sustainability of poplar stands.
Chemical control of P. tabaniformis can be achieved by injections of insecticides into larval galleries, spraying of poplar stems and branches, and application of granular systemic insecticides to the soil.
Introduction or injection of insecticides such as dimethoate, fenvalerate, deltamethrin, or cypermethrin at high rates into larval galleries in July and August can be highly effective in small tree stands (Dafauce and Astiaso, 1964; Vasiæ, 1967; Bertucci, 1986). However, this method is not used yet in practice because it is too expensive in comparison with traditional sprayings.
Chemical control of P. tabaniformis is usually based on three to four sprayings at 15-day intervals starting from mid-June at the beginning of larval hatching (Lapietra and Allegro, 1994).
In strongly damaged poplar plantations, three treatments at 4- to 5-weekly intervals with persistant insecticides such as fenthion and dimethoate gives high mortality (95-100%) of newly hatched larvae (Ceianu et al., 1973; Dafauce, 1975; Georgiev, 1995b). However, these insecticides are strongly toxic and not selective, and affect not only the pest, but also many beneficial insects (bees, parasitoids and predators). Five treatments with pyrethroids from early June to early August also give complete control (Wouters, 1979).
Granular systemic insecticides (e.g. dimethoate) applied to soil have some positive effects against P. tabaniformis (Ceianu et al., 1973; Lapietra, 1978; Moraal, 1989b). However, they cannot be recommended for insect control because of their insufficient and unstable effect.
In China, mass trapping of male adults using sex pheromones has been successfully applied to control P. tabaniformis (Du et al., 1985; Miao et al., 1987; Wu et al., 1987; Zhao and Li, 1989). According to Du et al. (1985), mass trapping results in 57-95% pest reduction in the next generation of the pest. Fifteen to thirty traps/ha are necessary in lightly to heavily damaged forests. According to Moraal et al. (1993), however, mass trapping is not efficient in preventing pest attacks.
ReferencesTop of page
Acatay A, 1959. Pappelschädlinge in der Türkei. Anzeiger für Schadlingskunde, 32 (9):129-134.
Alpheraky SN, 1882. Lépidoptères du district de Kouldjà et des montagnes environnantes. Horae Societatis Entomologicae Rossicae, 17:15-103.
Arru GM; Lapietra G, 1974. Sull, uso degli insetticidi sistemici contro gli insetti daniosi al pioppo in Italia. Cellulosa e carta, 5:50-60.
Bartel M, 1912. Familie: Aegeriidae (Sesiidae). In: Seitz A, ed. Die Gross-Schmetterlinge der Erde, I. Abteilung: Die Gross-Schmetterlinge des palaearctischen Faunengebietes. Stuttgart, A. Kernen, 2 (Die palaearctischen Spinner and SchwSrmer): 375-416.
Buda VG; Karalyus VA; Tat'yanskaite LI, 1988. Behaviour of dusky clearwing females Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. (Lepidoptera Sesiidae) during pheromone release and localization of pheromone gland. Khemoretseptsiya Nasekomykh, No. 10:5-14
Cavalcaselle B, 1975. Possibility of using products based on Beauveria bassiana (Bals.) Vuill. Against the larvae of some wood-eating insects. Mededelingen van de Faculteit Landbouwwetenschappen Rijksuniversiteit Gent, 437-442
Ceballos G, 1960. Cuatro icneumonidos parasitos de insectos de interes forestal. Bol. Serv. Plagas For., Madrid, 3(5):15-16.
Ceianu I, 1962. Contributii la cunoasterea dannatorului Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. (Lepidoptera, Aegeriidae) in R.P.R. Studii si Cercetari, INCEF, 22:91-115.
Ceianu I; Radoi D; Coca C, 1973. Control of Paranthrene tabaniformis on Poplar. Studii si Cercetari, Institutul de Cercetare, Proiectare si Documentare Silvica, I Silvicultura, 29:29-53.
Ceianu I; Radoi D; Konstantinescu E, 1967. Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. Cercetari cu privire la biologie si combatere. Centrul de documentare tehnica pentru economia forestiera. Bucharest: "13 Dec 1918" Pbs.
Chodjai M, 1977. Poplar pests of Iran and the Mideast. In: Thielges BA, Land SB Jr, ed. Proceedings: symposium on eastern cottonwood and related species. Greenville, Mississippi Sept. 28 - Oct. 2, 1976. Louisiana State University Division of Continuing Education. Baton Rouge USA, 295-300
Dafauce C; Astiaso F, 1964. Combate del Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. (Aegeridae-Lepidoptera) insecto perforador del chopo. Boletin del Servicio de Plagas Forestales, 13:23-29.
de Freina JJ, 1997. Die Bombyces und Sphinges der Westpalearktis. Band 4, Sesiidae. München, Germany: Edition Forschung & Wissenschaft Verlag GmbH, 52-55.
Denis M; Schiffermüller I, 1775. Ankündung eines systematischen Werkes von den Schmetterlingen der Wienergegend. Vienna, Austria: Bernardi.
Du J; Xu S; Dai X; Xi Z, 1984. Field test on controlling poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis Root by mass trapping. Contr. Shanghai Inst. Entomol., 4:53-58 (in Chinese).
Du J; Xu S; Dai X; Xi Z, 1985. Strategies for control poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis Root by mass trapping. Contr. Shanghai Inst. Entomol., 5:19-24 (in Chinese).
Edwards H, 1882. Notes on North American Aegeriides, with description of New Forms. Papilio, 2:52-57.
Eichlin TD; Duckworth WD, 1988. The Moths of America North of Mexico Including Greenland. Fascicle 5.1 Sesioidea Sesiidae. Washington, USA: The Wedge Entomological Research Foundation, 36-37.
Engelhardt GP, 1946. The North American Clearwing Moths of the Family Aegeriidae. United States National Museum Bulletin, 190:1-222.
Fibiger M; Kristensen NP, 1974. The Sesiidae (Lepidoptera) of Fennosscandia and Denmark. Fauna Entomologica Scandinavica. Vol. 2. Copenhagen, Denmark: E.J.Briil/Scandinavian Science Press Ltd.
Freyer CF, 1842. Neuere Beiträge zur Schmetterlingskunde mit Abbildungen nach der Natur. Vol. 4, Augsburg.
Georgiev G, 1995. Phenology of the poplar clearwing moth (Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott., Lepidoptera: Aegeriidae) in Northern Bulgaria. Forest Science, 1:60-67 (in Bulgarian, English summary).
Georgiev G, 1995. The poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis (Rottemburg, 1775) (Lepidoptera: Sesiidae) - biology, ecology and possibilities for controlling it in North Bulgaria. PhD Thesis. Forest Research Institute in Sofia (in Bulgarian).
Georgiev G, 2000. Parasitoids of Paranthrene tabaniformis (Rott.) (Lepidoptera: Sesiidae) in Bulgaria. Annual of Sofia University "St. Kliment Ohridski", Faculty of Biology, Book 2 - Zoology, 92:121-126 (in Bulgarian, English summary).
Georgiev G, 2000. Studies on larval parasitoids of Paranthrene tabaniformis (Rott.) (Lepidoptera: Sesiidae) on urban poplars (Populus spp.) in Sofia, Bulgaria. Annals of Forest Science, 57(2):181-186; 23 ref.
Georgiev G, 2001. Bioecological characteristics of two Pristomerus (Hymenoptera: Ichneumonidae) species as parasitoids of poplar borer insects in Bulgaria. In: Naydenova Ts, ed. Proceedings of the Third Balkan Scientific Conference, Study, Conservation and Utilization of Forest Resources, 2-6 October 2001, Sofia, Bulgaria, Vol. III: 101-110.
Georgiev G, 2001. Notes on the biology and ecology of the parasitoids of the poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis (Rott.) (Lep., Sesiidae) in Bulgaria. I. Apanteles evonymellae (Bouché, 1834) (Hym., Braconidae). Journal of Applied Entomology, 125(3):141-145; 18 ref.
Georgiev G, 2001. Notes on the biology and ecology of the parasitoids of the poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis (Rott.) (Lep., Sesiidae) in Bulgaria. II. Eriborus terebrans (Gravenhorst, 1826) (Hym., Ichneumonidae). Journal of Applied Entomology, 125(6):289-292; 23 ref.
Georgiev G; Delkov A, 1997. Phytophagous insects and their parasitoids on poplar trees in Sofia. Acta entomologica bulgarica, 1-2:61-65 (in Bulgarian, English summary).
Georgiev G; Kolarov J, 1999. New Ichneumonidae (Hymenoptera) parasitoids on forest insect pests in Bulgaria. Anzeiger für Schädlingskunde, 72(3):57-61.
Georgiev G; Tsankov G, 1995. Some parasitoid insect species on the larvae of the poplar clearwing moth (Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott., Lepidoptera: Sesiidae) in Bulgaria. Forest Science, 2: 51-58 (in Bulgarian, English summary).
Georgopulos A, 1956. Pappelschädling in Griechenland - zugleich ein Beitrag zur Biologie von Sciapteron tabaniformis and Melanophila decastigma. Anzeiger für Schadlinskunde, 29(8):127-131.
Grechkin VP; Vorontzov AI, 1962. Vrediteli i bolezni topolei i meri lorbi s nim. Moskow, Russian Federation: Goslesbumizdat, (in Russian).
Gyorfi J, 1959. Neure Beitrage zur Kenntis der Wirte der Braconiden (Hymenoptera, Braconidae). Beitrage zur Entomologie, 9(1-2):140-143.
Györfi J, 1963. Beitrage zur Biologie und Ökologie der Schlupfwespen (Ichneumonidae). Z. f. angew. Entomologie, 51(2):142-147.
Harris TW, 1839. Descriptive Catalogue of North American Insects, Belonging to the Linnean Genus Sphinx, etc. American Journal of Science, 36:282-320.
Hubenov Z; Georgiev G, 1996. Phytomyptera nigrina (Meig.) (Diptera, Tachinidae) - new parasitoid on poplar clearwing moth (Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott.) (Lepidoptera, Sesiidae). Forest science, 4:87-89 (in Bulgarian, English summary).
Hübner J, 1790. Beiträge zur Geschichte der Schmetterlinge. Vol. 2, Augsburg.
Hübner J, 1819. Verzeichniss bekannter Schmetterlinge. Augsburg, 17-176.
Jodal I, 1967. O problemima vaznijih ksilofagnih insekata topola i vrba u proteklih deset godina. Topola, 61/64:139-143.
Jodal I, 1986. Stetni insecti. In: Guzina V, ed. Topole i vrbe u Jugoslaviju. Novi Sad, Yugoslavia: Kultura, 209-219.
Kailidis DS, 1962. Observations on the biology and control of Sciapteron tabaniformis Rott. in Greece. Athens, Greece: Ministry of Agriculture, Directory General of Forest and Mountain Hydronomy, Forest Research Institute, 6:1-15 (in Greek, English summary).
Kailidis DS, 1970. Das Pappelinsektenproblem in Griechenland. Anzeiger für Schädlingskunde und Pflanzenschutz, 11:167-171.
Keremidciev M, 1966. Résistance de quelques groupes de peupliers aux insectes ravageurs. Forest Science, 5:401-411 (in Bulgarian, French summary).
Kolarov J; Georgiev G, 1997. New Pimplinae (Hymenoptera, Ichneumonidae) parasitoids of poplar clearwing moth (Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott., Lepidoptera: Sesiidae). Forest Science, 1-2:130-134.
Kozhanchikov IV, 1955. Aegeriidae. In: Pavlovskii EN, ed.: Forest Pests. Moscow-Leningrad, Russian Federation: Academy of Science of USSR Pbl., 1:57-61 (in Russian).
La Salle J; Huang DW, 1994. Two new Eulophidae (Hymenoptera: Chalcidoidea) of economic importance from China. Bulletin of Entomological Research, 84:51-56.
Lapietra G, 1967. The importance of natural enemies in the control of Paranthrene [Sciapteron] tabaniformis in N. Italy. In: Proc. 14th Congr. Int. Union For. Res. Organ., Munich 1967, Pt. V, Sect. 24:629-34.
Lapietra G, 1976. Resistenza agli insetti di 10 cloni di pioppo al 1 anno di vivario. Cellulosa e carta, 11:22-30.
Lapietra G, 1978. Pratiche applicazioni di insetticidi sistemici nella difesa del vivaio di pioppo di 1 anno. Cellulosa e Carta, 29(6):25-32.
Laspeyres JH, 1801. Sesia Europaeae et discriptionibus illustratae. Berolini.
Lastuvka Z; Lastuvka A, 1995. An Illustrated Key to European Sesiidae (Lepidoptera). Brno, Czech Republic: Konvoj Pbl.
Le Cerf F, 1916. Contribution. In: Oberthür C, ed. Explication des planches. Études de Lépidoptérologie Comparée, 11.
Miao JC; Jiang RH; Xu BR; Han WX; Su GQ; Li WH; Deng LW, 1985. Experiments on the sex pheromone of the poplar clearwing moth Paranthrene tabaniformis and technique of application. Journal of North-East Forestry University, China, 13(3):123-127
Miao JC; Liu XL; Xu BR; Can WC; Li WM, 1987. Study on the attraction effect and technical application of sex pheromone of poplar clearwing moth Paranthrene tabaniformis. Journal of North-East Forestry University, China, 15(1):30-39
Moraal LG, 1987. Apanteles evonymellae fauna n. sp., a new parasitoid of the poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis (Hymenoptera: Braconidae; Lepidoptera: Sesiidae). Entomologische Berichten, 47(9):137-139
Moraal LG, 1989. Telenomus phalaenarum fauna nov. spec., as an egg parasitoid of the poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis (Hymenoptera: Scelionidae; Lepidoptera; Sesiidae). Entomologische Berichten, 49(5):65-68
Moraal LG, 1996. Evaluation of infestations by the poplar clearwing moth, Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. In: Bach I, ed. Proceedings of the 20th Session of the International Poplar Commission. Budapest, 1-4 October 1996, 1:250-259.
Morris RF, 1956. Note on Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott., a Moth New to North America (Lepidoptera: Aegeriidae). Canadian Entomologist, 88(11):652.
Newman E, 1832. Sphinx vespiformis: An Essay. London, UK: F. Westley and A.H. Davis.
Nogueira CDS; Ferreira LJC, 1968. Pests of Poplar. Folh. Divulg. Serv. Flor. Aquic. Portugal, No 5.
Postner M, 1978. Familienreihe Aegeridoidea. In: Schwenke W, ed. Die Forstschädlinge Europas. 3 Band, Schmeterlinge. Hamburg und Berlin, Germany: Paul Parey, 188-205.
Rambur JP, 1866. Catalogue systematique des lépidoptéres de l'Andalousie. Paris, France: Bailliere, 93-412.
Rohrig E, 1953. Der kleine Pappelglasschwärmer (Sciapteron tabanifformis Rott.) als Schädling an Jungpappeln. Allg. Forstzeitschrift, 41:451-452.
Rottemburg SA von, 1775. Anmercungen zu den hufnagelschen Tabellen der Schmetterlinge. Der Naturforscher (Halle), 7:105-112.
Schmutzenhofer H; Mielke ME; Luo Y; Ostry ME; Wen J, 1996. Field Guide/Manual on the Identification and Management of Poplar Pests and Diseases in the Area of the "Three North 009 Project" (North-Eastern China). Rome, Italy: FAO.
Schnaiderova J, 1980. The dusky clearwing - Paranthrene tabaniformis. Prace Institutu Badawczego Lesnicestwa, 565/572:47-74.
Schnaiderowa J; Swiezynska H, 1977. Proby zwalczania przeziernika topolowca (Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. - Aegeriidae, Lep.) owadobojczym grzybem Beauveria bassiana (Bals.) Vuill. Sylwan, 121(6):23-29.
South R, 1939. The Moths of the British Isles. Second Series, The Families Noctuidae to Hepialidae. London, UK: Frederick Warne & Co. Ltd., 351-352.
Srot M, 1958. Nesytka ovadova, prehlizeny scudce topoli. Lesn. Prace, 37(8):364-367.
Srot M, 1966. Nectere poznatky z bionomie nesytky ovadove (Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott.) v CSSR a moznosti boje proti ni. Prace vyzkumneho ustavu lesnino hospodarstvo a myslivosti, 32:15-41.
Strojny W, 1958. Insects destructive to de wood of fast growing trees. Part IV. Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. (Lepidoptera, Aegeriidae). Polskie Pismo Entomologiczne, 28(10):151-156 (in Polish, English summary).
Suhareva IL, 1978. Sesiidae. In: Medvediev GS, ed. Insect Key for the European Part of the USSR. Leningrad, Russian Federation: Nauka, 4(1):156-177 (in Russian).
Szontagh P, 1965. A Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott. hazai eletmodja es karositasa. Allattani Közlemenyek, 52(1-4):135-142 (in Hungarian).
Szontagh P, 1965. Az üvegszárnyú lepkék (fam. Aegeriidae) kártétele nyár anyatelepeken. Erdészeti kutatások, 17:257-275 (in Hungarian, German summary).
Templado J, 1964. Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott., importante plaga del chopo. Publicaciones del Instituto de Biologia Aplicada, Barcelona, 37:33-52.
Thompson WR, 1957. A catalogue of the parasites and predators of insect pests. Section 2, Part 4. Commonwealth Agricultural Bureau, Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control. Ottawa, Ontario, 333-561.
Timchenko GA, 1965. Xylophagous pests and their control in Eastern parts of Ukraine. Lesnoe hoziaistvo, 1, 3 (in Russian).
Tobias V, 1986. Insect Key for the European part of the USSR. Leningrad, Russian Federation: Nauka, 3(4) (in Russian).
Toth J, 1970. Insect infestation in Populeta in the Great Hungarian Plain. Erdo, 20(3):127-131.
Vasic M, 1966. Traianje razvica malog topolinog staclocrilca (Sciapteron -Paranthrene tabaniformis Rott.) u ekoloskim uslovima istocne Slavonie i Baranje. Topola, 59/60:38-44.
Vasic M, 1967. Uredaj za suzbijanje insecata u zivom drevu hemijkim sredstvima. Topola, 65/66:18-28.
Wouters LA, 1979. Control of Sciapteron [Paranthrene] tabaniformis larvae in poplar nurseries. Populier, 16(2):39-40.
Wouters LJA, 1977. Het gebruik van parasitaire aaltjes voor de bestrijding van larven van de populiereglasvlinder. Populier, 14(3):59-60.
Yüksel B, 1998. The damaging insect species in the nurseries of Central and Eastern Black Sea Region and theirs control methods. Ormancilik Arastirma Enstitüsü Yayinlari, Teknik Bülten, 7, Trabzon.
Distribution MapsTop of page
Unsupported Web Browser:
One or more of the features that are needed to show you the maps functionality are not available in the web browser that you are using.
Please consider upgrading your browser to the latest version or installing a new browser.
More information about modern web browsers can be found at http://browsehappy.com/