Pieris brassicae (large white or cabbage white butterfly); final instar larva, from oilseed rape plants (Brassica napus var. napus). Kent, UK. November, 2014.
Pieris brassicae (large white or cabbage white butterfly); final instar larva, from oilseed rape plants (Brassica napus var. napus). Kent, UK. November, 2014.
English:
cabbage caterpillar; cabbage white; cabbage worm; great white butterfly; great white cabbage butterfly; large garden white butterfly; large white butterfly; large white cabbage butterfly; white butterfly, large
Spanish:
aruga de la col; gran mariposa blanca de la col; gusano de las hojas de hortaliza; oruga verde de la col
French:
grand papillon blanc du chou; piéride du chou
Top of page
The subspecies on the Canary Islands (P. brassicae cheiranthi) is regarded by some authors as being specifically distinct. The similar P. brassicae wollastoni, which is confined to above 1000 m altitude on Madeira, is often included in this subspecies.
See Notes on distribution for information on other subspecies and closely related species.
Bright yellow, bottle-shaped, 1.4 mm high, ribbed vertically and laid upright in clusters of 40-100. Change to bright orange prior to hatching.
Larvae
Newly-emerged larvae are yellow with shiny black heads. After the first moult the colour changes to yellowish-green with yellow lines running the length of the body. On the back and sides there are numerous hair-topped tubercles, which give the larva a rugose texture.
Fully-fed larvae are 45 mm long, basically olive-green (more greyish dorsally) with a pronounced yellow dorsal line, either side of which are dorso-lateral black spots and squares. The whole body is covered with fine, hair-bearing tubercles, many of which are also black. The head is bluish-grey with black patches.
Pupae
Length 20 mm. Pale green (non-diapausing) or greyish-white (diapausing) and dotted with black and yellow markings. The ventral surface is flattened. There is a lateral ridge along either side, and a similar ridge extends from the forward-pointing head up over the head, thorax and abdomen. Several blunt spikes are also found on the abdomen. Found on walls, fencing, tree-trunks and stones, or under roofs and branches, and attached to the substrate by a silken girdle and pad. The final colour matches the substrate.
Adults
Wingspan 55-70 mm, with females being larger than the males. The wing uppersides of both sexes are usually gleaming white, with a pronounced black tip to the forewing. This is augmented in the female (which has a larger black tip) by a pair of post-discal black spots, with a black smear along the inner margin below the lower spot. The undersides of both sets of wings are pale yellow dusted with grey, except for the centre and base of the forewings, which are white. In females, the black dots of the forewings also appear on the undersides. The head, thorax and abdomen are black with grey hair-like scales.
There is a little variation: in ab. flava the ground colour is sulphur-yellow; in ab. carnea it is tinged pink; in ab. coerulea the yellow of the hindwing underside is replaced by bluish green; in ab. striata Rocci the apical black patch is continued inwards as rays along the veins; and ab. albinensis is devoid of any black scales (Maitland-Emmet and Heath, 1989).
In the subspecies from the Canary Islands (P. brassicae cheiranthi), the black markings are enlarged, with the underside of the hindwings and underside forewing tips being bright yellow.
P. brassicae catoleuca from the Levant differs from the nominate subspecies in being larger, in having the black spots of the forewing undersides slightly co-joined by a bridge of black scaling in the female and in lacking the black scaling on the undersides of the hindwings.
In 1994, P. brassicae was reported as having established itself in the western Cape, South Africa (Claassens, 1995).
P. brassicae was recorded for the first time from Delhi in February 1996. Its very high incidence was unusual, as it is primarily a pest in mountainous areas (Bhalla et al., 1997).
The subspecies P. brassicae catoleuca is found in the Levant (Larsen, 1974; Benyamini, 1990).
In Nepal, India and Tibet (Xizhang) and Yunnan, China, this species occurs as subspecies P. brassicae nepalensis.
P. brassicae is replaced in the highlands of Ethiopia and northern Tanzania by the closely related Pieris brassicoides, which flies above 2000 m altitude (Carcasson, 1981).
In the eastern Palaearctic this species is replaced by Pieris canidia.
The distribution in this summary table is based on all the information available. When several references are cited, they may give conflicting information on the status. Further details may be available for individual references in the Distribution Table Details section which can be selected by going to Generate Report.
Top of page
Because of its migratory nature, this species can be found almost anywhere; however, it does show a preference for cultivated areas, where species of Brassicaceae are cultivated, and urban gardens. In Europe, small populations still breed along sea cliffs, in large woodland clearings and on steep rocky hillsides, which appear to have been the original habitats of this species.
Larsen (1974) recorded this species as feeding on Capparis in Lebanon. Records of Malus domestica (apple), Pisum sativum (pea) and Solanum melongena (aubergine) are very doubtful.
Feeding, growth, development and oviposition preferences of P. brassicae have been studied on cole crops in the laboratory in India. Final-instar larvae preferred sarson [Brassica rapa subsp. trilocularis], cabbage and Brassica juncea (Indian mustard) to cauliflower, whereas toria [Brassica rapa subsp. dichotoma] was less preferred. Adults oviposited only on cruciferous plants, no eggs being laid on wheat, gram (Cicer arietinum) or pea. The maximum number of eggs were laid on cauliflower, followed by cabbage and Indian mustard. The larvae completed their development in 26.60-28.03 days. Development was faster on Indian mustard, toria, cauliflower and cabbage than on sarson. The greatest number of adults emerged on cabbage and the growth index was highest on this food plant. It is concluded that, in India, cabbage is most susceptible to attack by P. brassicae, followed by cauliflower, Indian mustard, sarson and toria (Tiwari and Kashyap, 1988).
Top of page
Larvae of this species often strip growing shoots and even whole plants, particularly in the final instar. In badly infested cabbage fields only the major leaf veins may be left.
Top of page
P. brassicae is naturally nomadic. It does not live in identifiable, permanent colonies but breeds wherever suitable conditions are encountered. Under optimum conditions, enormous numbers can build up which then explode outwards in strong migrations. For this reason, and because of high levels of parasitism, numbers of this species can fluctuate wildly from year to year in any given locality.
A mass migration of P. brassicae was recorded in Kashmir, India, on 28 May 1988. It was estimated that at least 75,000 to 80,000 butterflies passed one site in a northerly direction at altitudes of 3800-4000 m in 1.5 days, this being only a small proportion of the total population (Jamdar, 1991).
This butterfly was very abundant in the UK in 1992. The timing of systematic counts, anecdotal reports of exceptional local abundance and frequent counts at a coastal site, cast doubt on the importance of immigration in contributing to the large populations. Emergence within the UK was suggested (Pollard, 1994).
In northern Europe, including England, there are two generations per year, with adults first appearing in late April and May. The second brood usually appears in late July and August. Further south in Europe there is usually a third brood in October, and there may be as many as four broods in Malta (Valletta, 1972). The adults are attracted to blue and purple flowers and, during a migration or population explosion, can be seen in large numbers on lavender, Salvia, Buddleia and similar plants.
This species ascends to 3000 m altitude in the Alps of Europe (Vorbrodt and Müller-Rutz, 1911) and to over 2000 m in Lebanon (Larsen, 1974).
In Israel, adults can be found from February until December (Benyamini, 1990). In Malta it can be seen all year round, although it is rarer during the dry summer and the colder months of December and January; however, the local population is massively re-enforced by large numbers of immigrants during spring and autumn (Valletta, 1972).
At Barapani, Meghalaya, India, there are four generations of this species, with two overlapping generations at low and mid altitudes and two or three generations at high altitudes. The winter generations have a longer life cycle than those during the summer and rainy seasons. Higher temperatures directly influence different stages. A temperature range of 15.2-30°C was found to be ideal for multiplication during May-June. However, other abiotic parameters did not influence the life cycle (Thakur and Deka, 1997b).
The larvae are gregarious for most of their life, only becoming semi-independent towards the end of the final instar. When fully grown they leave the host to find a place to pupate on or under some protective surface off the ground. This may be some distance away from where it fed.
All larvae readily regurgitate a thick, repellent, green liquid from their guts to deter predators and parasitoids.
The two main natural enemies of this species are Cotesia glomerata (larvae) and Pteromalus puparum (pupae). In some areas of Europe, up to 100% of the early stages may be destroyed by these parasitoids alone (Sengonca and Peters, 1991). Although Cotesia rubecula will develop in P. brassicae, its preferred host is Pieris rapae (Harvey et al., 1999)
Ecological studies on the natural enemies of both larvae and pupae of P. brassicae in Himachal Pradesh, India, showed that the parasitoids Cotesia glomerata and Hyposoter ebeninus, the predatory syrphid Episyrphus balteatus and the entomopathogens Bacillus sp., Entomophthora sp. and Serratia marcescens, caused mortality of 31% (Sood and Bhalla, 1996).
In a survey of the distribution, injuriousness and natural enemies of P. brassicae on cruciferous crops in Pakistan, this pierid was the most serious pest of brassicas in the Sialkot area. Cotesia glomerata, Diadegma pierisae and Pteromalus puparum were the commonest parasitoids in most areas (Mushtaque, 1989).
During a long-term study of Nosema mesnili infections in natural populations of P. brassicae in north-western Russia, a regular massive occurrence (once every 4-8 years) of another microsporidian, Thelohania mesnili, was observed (Sokolova and Issi, 1997).
Studies in cabbage crops in the Ukraine showed that parasitism of larvae and pupae of P. brassicae by Cotesia glomerata and Pteromalus puparum was as high as 60-65% and 25-30%, respectively, at 10-15 m from a source of flower nectar, but these figures were more than halved at 50 m (Yastrebov, 1991).
A study carried out between 1980 and 1983 to determine the natural enemies associated with eggs, larvae and pupae of P. brassicae collected from cultivated crucifers in Valdivia, Chile, found no natural enemies at the egg stage. However, 82.24% of the larvae were parasitized by Cotesia glomerata and an Apanteles sp. Both of these braconids were attacked by hyperparasitoids of the genera Hemicallidiotes, Isdromas and Perissocentrus. Various bacteria infected 15.63% of the larvae. In the pupal stage, the natural enemies and their average rates of parasitism were: Pteromalus puparum 6.75%, the ichneumonid Pimpla fuscipes 23.37% and the fungus Beauveria brongniartii 5.82%. During the period of the study, 0.74% of the immature stages of P. brassicae became adults (Neira et al., 1989).
Hasan and Ansari (2010; 2011) reported P. brassicae (L.) to be one of the most destructive and cosmopolitan pests of cruciferous crops in India, where it causes 40% of the damage to cruciferous crops per year. In Himachal Pradesh, India, P. brassicae completes three generations in a year, the duration of which vary from 32-64 days. The first two generations during February-May inflict severe damage to cabbage and cauliflower. High temperatures and more sunshine hours, accompanied by low relative humidity and rainfall, favour population build-ups (Sood and Bhalla, 1996).
In a field study in 1991-92 at Upper Shillong, Meghalaya, India with cabbage cv. Pride of India, 68.5% of the marketable yield was affected by attack by larvae of P. brassicae. Larval population and yield correlation indicated that the damage was significant 22-25 days and 40-47 days after sowing (Thakur, 1996).
It was estimated that at Izmir, Turkey, damage caused by P. brassicae to cabbages in 1985 and 1986 averaged 40.45%, and to cauliflowers 27.06% (Atalay and Hincal, 1992).
In Sierra Nevada, western USA, Shapiro (1975) reported that Pieris spp. were serious pest of cruciferous crops and caused 41% annual losses in crucifers.
Detection and Inspection
Top of page
Numerous holes appearing in young leaves are usually the first sign of an infestation. Turning over shoots will reveal large clusters of young larvae resting beneath the leaves. Older larvae usually rest quite openly on the leaf upperside. The presence of adults flying around cruciferous crops will also indicate that egg-laying is taking place and that damage is to be expected later.
Adults are similar in both appearance and behaviour to Pieris rapae; however, the latter is generally much smaller, with the black tip to the forewing upperside being confined to the extreme tip and not extending down the outer edge. The larva of P. rapae is very different, in being solitary and predominantly green.
In several experiments in 1987 and 1988 in Germany, cauliflower fields planted from May to July were covered with netting (Rantai K). Covering the crop for 4-5 weeks in the first few weeks after planting was sufficient to exclude and control P. brassicae (Wonneberger and Gawehn, 1989).
Chemical Control
Ram and Pathak (1992) reported the effectiveness of carbaryl and dimethoate in reducing P. brassicae infestation on cabbage in field trials in Manipur, India.
Eleven insecticides were evaluated for control of P. brassicae in cabbage cv. Pride of India growing at Barapani, Meghalaya, India, during 1991-92. Plants were sprayed twice, once at the preheading stage and again at post-heading. Overall, fenvalerate gave virtually 100% control of P. brassicae, followed by deltamethrin (97.3%), cypermethrin (96.8%), malathion (96.08%) and fenitrothion (93.3%). Chlorpyrifos, quinalphos and diflubenzuron were the least effective of the tested insecticides. The highest yield was obtained in fenvalerate-treated plots. The cost-benefit ratio was also highest for fenvalerate (Thakur and Deka, 1997a).
Destruxins produced by the entomogenous fungus Metarhizium anisopliae have been tested for their effects on first instar larvae of P. brassicae. Different concentrations of crude destruxin, pure destruxin A, pure destruxin E and a synthetic analogue, Hpy-6 dtx E, were used. First-instar larvae of P. brassicae were very sensitive to crude destruxin, exhibiting high mortality levels after 36 hours (Eilenberg and Thomsen, 1998).
The use of insecticides in an integrated control programme has to be undertaken with care due to their toxicity to natural enemies. Eleven insecticides at the recommended field dosages were evaluated for their toxicity to the braconid Cotesia glomerata. Diflubenzuron, fenvalerate, cypermethrin and deltamethrin proved very safe, whereas malathion, chlorpyrifos and quinalphos proved toxic within 24 hours. Residual toxicity of fenitrothion dropped significantly within 7 days of treatment whereas malathion had significantly high residual toxicity up to 21 days. It was concluded that the use of the above mentioned synthetic pyrethroids and diflubenzuron on cabbage at the recommended dosages was safe to C. glomerata. In the case of fenitrothion, release of C. glomerata should not be made until 7 days after spraying (Thakur and Deka, 1995).
Biopesticides and Botanicals
Field studies have been conducted in India using two formulations of neem (extracts of Azadirachta indica) against larvae of P. brassicae in cabbage fields. Larval mortality was highest 7 days after treatment, with death-rates varying between 73.33 and 86.66%. The neem formulations were safer to the parasitoid Cotesia glomerata, which parasitized the P. brassicae larvae (Dhaliwal et al., 1998). Neem also reduced the survival of P. brassicae larvae feeding on cabbage leaves treated with the neem extract (Grisakova et al., 2006).
1% azadirachtin water emulsions showed repellent action to P. brassicae (Luik and Viidalepp, 2001). Aqueous extracts of Melia azedarach leaves and seeds have also been shown to have significant antifeedant and deterrent action towards P. brassicae (Singh et al., 1987; Osman and Port, 1990; Sharma and Gupta, 2009). Leatemia et al. (2004) found crude seed extracts of Annona squamosa to be effective against P. brassicae. Mixtures of Piper retrofractum (Piperaceae) + Annona squamosa (Annonaceae) extracts and Aglaia odorata (Meliaceae) + A. squamosa extracts were found to be effective against P. brassicae (Dadang et al., 2009).
Jaquet et al., (1986) reported that the larvae of P. brassicae were highly susceptible to purified crystals of strains of Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt) subsp. thuringiensis. The pest was also susceptible to Beauveria bassiana and Metarhizium anisopilae (Sabbour and Sahab, 2005). CAMB Bt-based biopesticides were found to be effective against P. brassicae on cauliflower (Zafar et al., 2002). Toxicity of Bt against P. brassicae larvae was also reported by Lama (1990) and Prabhakar and Bishop (2009). Klokocar-Šmit et al. (2007) investigated the effects of formulations based on B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki and spinosad on P. brassicae instars 2, 3, 4 and 5 and found the effect of insecticides to be inversely proportional to larval instars. Spinosad was more effective in inducing mortality and reducing leaf damage by all larval instars than formulations based on B. thuringiensis subsp. kurstaki. Harris and Maclean (1999) also reported superiority of Spinosad over other pesticides against this pest.
APPPC, 1987. Insect pests of economic significance affecting major crops of the countries in Asia and the Pacific region. Technical Document No. 135. Bangkok, Thailand: Regional Office for Asia and the Pacific region (RAPA)
Dadang EDF, Djoko P, 2009. Effectiveness of two botanical insecticide formulations to two major cabbage insect pests on field application. Journal of International Society for Southeast Asian Agricultural Sciences, 15(1):42-51
Eilenberg J, Thomsen L, 1998. Metabolites from insect-pathogenic fungi: new natural compounds with potential for insect pest control. DJF Rapport, Markbrug, (No. 3). Tjele, Denmark: Danmarks JordbrugsForskning, 89-96
Gupta PR, Sood A, 2002. Biological control of lepidopteran pests. In: Proceedings of the Symposium of Biological Control of Lepidopteran Pests, Bangalore, India
Klokocar-Šmit ZD, Indic DV, Vukovic SM, Filipovic MM, Cervenski JF, 2007. Preliminary investigation on the effects of biological and synthetic insecticides on large white butterfly (Pieris brassicae L.) larvae. Zbornik Matice srpske za prirodne nauke [Matica srpska Journal for Natural Sciences], 112:75-82
Matsuda M, Yamada T, Kimura T, Ishitani M, Kinota M, Kudo Y, 1997. Occurrence and hibernation of the large white butterfly, Pieris brassicae Linnaeus, in Aomori Prefecture in 1996. Annual Report of the Society of Plant Protection of North Japan, No. 48:178-180; 5 ref
Ojha PK, Singh IP, Pandey NK, 2004. Comparitive efficacy of some new insecticides against insect pests of cauliflower under agro- climatic zone- 1 of Bihar. Pestology, 28(4):36-39
Popescu-Gorj A, 1964. Catalogue of the Lepidoptera collection of "Prof. A. Ostrogovich" in the Natural History Museum "Grigore Antipa" Bucarest. Bucarest, Romania: Musée d'Histoire Naturelle "Gr. Antipa"
Shapiro VA, 1975. Ecological behavioural aspects of consistence in six crucifers feeding Pierid butterflies in the central Sirra Nevada. Midland Naturalist, 93:424-433
Zafar U, Idrees N, Ahmad S, Ahmed AR, Muhammad S, Sheikh R, 2002. Performance evaluation of camb biopesticides to control cabbage butterfly (Pieris brassicae) in cauliflower crop. Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 5:1041-1043
